Why we cannot simply leave teaching to teachers: professional cultures and attitudes towards system assessment
Mariano Fernández Enguita's abstract for the international seminar "What are the strategic challenges behind the implementation of accountability in education policies?"
University of Salamanca
However, these two last options are those actually going but they do not seem to adequately guarantee the quality of education or even the smooth running of schools. This could be explained by two aspects (among others) that distinguish education from other professional contexts: the lack of an adult counterpart on the side of the public and the dissolution of hierarchy due to the atomization of the system in thousands of schools, classrooms, disciplines and functions.
All this makes necessary some form of standardization through the control of results (not only academic results, but also social, etc.), which constitutes the main reason for assessment in its different versions. But the very idea of assessment is fiercely resisted by the profession, for which it means a market logic, a political interference, a surrender to parents particularism or simple nonsense and impossibility. However, such a resistance should not be discussed on logical but on genealogical grounds, as one more instrument of professional social closure against the employer and the public.