School assessment and support in Europe: variety and hybridization mechanisms
Xavier Dumay abstract for the international seminar "What are the strategic challenges behind the implementation of accountability in education policies?".
GIRSEF, Université Catholique de Louvain
Emphasising these common points should not obliterate what is probably the most remarkable feature of European school systems and policies – variety. In this paper, we will seek to capture the variety of policies and accountability criteria in this European space and show to what extent the history of national school systems is a key factor in the hybridization of international policy orientations.
The paper is structured as followed: after describing the main converging points in the implementation of European education policies and the role of European political institutions in this harmonization process, we will focus on Sweden and England to show how the political transformations visible at European (and global) scale are hybridized by political, cultural, and epistemological traditions specific to these two countries.
Finally, we suggest a comparison of the school assessment and support process in these two school systems along three lines. The first addresses the theory of regulation and change that underlies the school assessment and support mechanisms. The second refers to the nature and meaning of power struggles and redistribution between central and local authorities. The third tackles the evolution of cognitive matrixes that have guided the emergence and transformation of accountability policies.