Symposium

THE SOCIOLOGY OF EDUCATION AND THE RESTRUCTURING OF THE STATE IN TIMES OF GLOBALISATION AND EUROPEAN CONSTRUCTION

Monday 22 and Tuesday 23 November 2010

Institut National de Recherche Pédagogique

This symposium will follow from the previous international events organised as part of the programme “measurement policies in a knowledge society” launched by the national research agency (ANR) in partnership with the ENS, the grande école in humanities. A first symposium addressed the transformations of the state and the forms of justice following the crisis of school democratisation. It was argued that the shift from “equal opportunities” to “equity” not only challenged the French welfare state model and its assessment instruments but also invited us to set these evolutions within a larger framework – the globalisation of educational systems and European construction. The second symposium open to Anglo-Saxon countries was the opportunity for a comparison of accountability-based educational reforms and for suggestions towards the modernisation of the French school model. This third symposium seeks to go deeper into the transformations of the regulating state in times of globalisation and European construction and determine the necessary changes for the sociology of education to take account of these transformations.

Go beyond a restrictive national framework and ultimately appreciate these transformations. It is also based on the experience of NESSE (the Network of Experts in the Social Sciences of Education and training) set up in 2006 by the European Commission’s DG EAC (the Directorate-General for Education and Culture). NESSE provides expertise in the preparation of the school modernisation project by 2010.

By opening the “black box” of academic education (Derouet, 1992), the sociology of education gained legitimacy as government science and expertise provider towards decision-making in as varied fields as decentralisation, the functioning of schools, guidance, assessment, curriculum, academic failure, teacher work, management’s skills, and the socialisation of students (Derouet, Van Zanten, 2000). It has also contributed to designing new tools to measure inequalities and substituted more targeted investigations into the factors behind academic success for large-scale statistical surveys (Duru-Bellat, 2002; Millet & Thin, 2005, Ben-Ayed, 2009).

This new sociology has focused on local issues and how stakeholders interact and mobilize at classroom, school and local levels. Despite this heuristic approach, the French sociology of education has remained impervious to scale changes imposed by globalisation and the European construction of education and research (Lauder and alii, 2006; Lawn & Novoa, 2005; Bruno, 2008). While French sociologists now fuel public debate on the relevance of international comparisons or on the challenges of the democratization of elites, they are still marked by Durkheimian tradition and Pierre Bourdieu’s legacy, whether they praise their virtues or expose their assumptions (Lahire, 1999; Baudelot & Establet, 2009; Dutercq, 2008). Although French sociology cannot be reduced to a state sociology, the French sociology of education seems relatively trapped in its methodological nationalism both in the design of its theoretical tools and ways of thinking (Poupeau, 2003; Meuret, 2007; Dubet, 2002).

The symposium aims to investigate this theoretical and methodological positioning, with an emphasis on the changes that have affected the field of education at international scale for some fifteen years. This is also the opportunity to assess twenty years of French sociological works and compare them to methods of analysis designed in other countries. The event will put in perspective the relationships between sociological theory and the State in its most recent transformations in terms of justice and government knowledge in education or in other fields of public action (Derouet & Derouet-Besson, 2009; Bezès, 2009; Pierru, 2007). The contribution of the sociologists of education to appreciating and renewing issues of social criticism (Boltanski, 2009) will be addressed. The place of sociology among other academic knowledge production, the competition between sociology and other forms of expertise and its degree of legitimacy in the policy and decision-making environment at national and international level will be examined (Calon and alii, 2001; Dumoulin and alii, 2005; lhl, 2006; Robert, 2008; Georgakakis and Lassale, 2007).

The symposium will also focus on the methodologies and comparative works that put some path dependencies into perspective or specify their singularirty (Dale, 1999; Maroy, 2006; Ball, 2008). Light will be thrown on the periods of mutual borrowing and of knowledge or instrument circulation from one space to another (Phillips, Ocks, 2003, 2004). The new approaches to the design of data, their comparability and totalisation will be compared to normative models borne by major international organisations (Osborn and alii, 2003). The symposium will also be the opportunity for interactions between the sociology of education and political sciences.

Three cross topics will be addressed

The impact of globalisation on the existing frameworks of analysis; major changes affecting national educational systems; the building of international networks of researchers, experts, and policymakers; the transnational circulation and dissemination of cultural, social, and political models; the alignment of educational policies with accountability principles; the way the sociology of education accounts for it in a comprehensive and critical perspective.

The European construction of education and its relation to the lifelong learning policy. How does the sociology of education tackle the deschooling of educational challenges? What is the right sociological framework to account for lifelong learning processes? How do sociologists shed light on the foundations and developments of the school modernisation project supported by European institutions?

The place of the sociology of education in a post welfare environment and its contribution to a renewed ideal of justice. Sociologists now focus on the recognition of differences after inquiring into the issue of inequalities. How do their analyses align with the emergence of a post welfare state? How does sociology rethink the project of equal opportunities and the integration of educational services into social inclusion policies, New Public Management, the merchandisation and privatisation of state education? Who are the new stakeholders and partners of the state? What are their claims and how do they take social and political action?

REFERENCES

Ball S., (2008). The Education Debate. Bristol : The Policy Press.

Baudelot C., Establet E. (2009) L’élitisme républicain. L’école française à l’heure des comparaisons internationales. Paris : Seuil.

Ben-Ayed C. (2009) Le nouvel ordre éducatif local. Mixité, disparités, luttes locales. Paris : PUF.

Bezès P., (2009), Réinventer l’État. Les réformes de l’administration française. Paris : PUF.

Boltanski L., (2010), De la critique. Précis de sociologie de l’émancipation. Paris : Gallimard.

Bruno I., (2008) À vos marques®, prêts… cherchez ! : la stratégie européenne de Lisbonne, vers un marché de la recherche, Bellecombe-en-Bauges, Éd. du Croquant.

Callon, M., Lascoumes, P. & Barthe, Y. (2001). Agir dans un monde incertain : essai sur la démocratie technique. Paris : Seuil.

Dale R., (1999) Specifying globalizing effects on a national policy in Journal of Education Policy, 14, 1, pp. 1-17.

Dumoulin L., Labranche S., Robert C., Warin P., (2005), Le recours aux experts. Raisons et usages politiques. Grenoble : Presses Universitaires de Grenoble.

Derouet J-L., (1992). École et justice. De l’égalité des chances aux compromis locaux ? Paris : Métailié.

Derouet J.-L., (2003). (dir.). Le collège unique en questions. Paris : PUF.

Derouet, J-L. & Derouet-Besson M.-C. (2009). Repenser la justice dans l’éducation et la formation. Berne : Peter Lang/INRP.

Dubet, F. (2002). Le déclin de l'institution. Paris : Seuil.

Dutercq Y. (2008) coord. Former des élites dans un monde incertain, Education & Sociétés n° 21.

Duru-Bellat, M. (2002). Les inégalités sociales à l'école. Genèse et mythes. Paris : PUF.

Georgakakis Didier et de Lasalle Marine (2007) La “nouvelle gouvernance européenne”. Genèses et usages politiques d’un livre blanc, Strasbourg, Presses Universitaires de Strasbourg.

Ihl O., Kaluszynski M., Pollet G., (dir.) (2003) Les sciences de gouvernement. Paris : Economica.

Lahire B., (dir.) (1999) Le travail sociologique de Pierre Bourdieu : dettes et critiques, Éd. la Découverte.

Lauder H., Brown P., Dillabough J.A., Halsey A.H., (eds.) (2006) Education, globalization and social change. Oxford : Oxford TextBooks.

Lawn M., Novoa A., (2005) L’Europe réinventée. Regards critiques sur l’espace européen de l’éducation, Paris : L’Harmattan.

Maroy C., (2006) École, régulation et marché : une comparaison de six espaces scolaires locaux en Europe, Paris : PUF.

Meuret D., (2007). Gouverner l'école : une comparaison France/États-Unis. Paris : PUF.

Millet, M. & Thin D. (2005). Ruptures scolaires : l'école à l'épreuve de la question sociale. Paris : PUF.

Osborn, M., Broadfoot, P., McNess, E., Ravn, R., Planel, C. & Triggs, P. with Cousin, O. & Winther-Jensen T. (2003). A World a difference ? Comparing Learners across Europe. Buchingham : Open University Press/McGraw-Hill Education.

Phillips D., Ochs K., (2003), Processes of policy borrowing in education : some explanatory and methodological devices in Compare, 39,4, pp. 451-461

Phillips D., Ochs K., (2004), Researching policy borrowing : some methodological challenges in comparative education in British Educational Research Journal, 30,6, pp. 773-784.

Pierru F., (2007), Hippocrate malade de ses réformes, Bellecombes-en-Beauge, Ed. Du Croquant

Poupeau F. (2003) Une sociologie d'État : l'école et ses experts en France, Raisons d'agir éditions.

Robert Cécile (2008), “Expertise et action publique” in Borraz Olivier et Guiraudon Virginie (dir.) Politiques publiques. 1. La France dans la gouvernance européenne, Paris, Presses de Sciences-Po.

Van Zanten, A. (2000). L’école : l’état des savoirs. Paris : La Découverte.

 

SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE

 

• Roger Dale, University of Bristol. Scientific coordinator of NESSE

• Jean-Louis Derouet, UMR Éducation & Politiques, INRP. NESSE member

• Romuald Normand, UMR Éducation & Politiques. INRP. NESSE member

• Thomas Popkievitz, University of WisconsinMadison

• Bruno Suchaut, IREDU

• Ronald Sultana, University of Malta. NESSE member

• Yves Winkin, Ecole Normale Supérieure LSH (humanities)

• Jean-Claude Zancarini, UMR Triangle, ENS-LSH

 

ORGANISATION COMMITTEE

Paul Assunçao, research administration department, INRP

Eve Albonico, UMR Education & Politiques, INRP

Jean-Louis Derouet, UMR Éducation & Politiques, INRP

Marie-Claude Derouet-Besson, UMR Éducation & Politiques, INRP

Romuald Normand, UMR Éducation & Politiques, INRP

Claudie Rouquet, UMR Éducation & Politiques, INRP

Guillaume Roussel, UMR Éducation & Politiques, INRP

Hervé Tugaut, International relations department, INRP

 

The sociology of education and the restructuring of the State in times of globalisation and European construction

 

Monday 22 November 2010

8.30am Welcoming visitors

9.00am Introduction Ministry officials : Olivier Faron, managing director of ENS

 

9.30am overview Jean-Louis Derouet (INRP)

 

 

First session: sociology of education, government science information and restructuring of the State

10.00am Thomas Popkewitz, University of Wisconsin-Madison

The Sociology of Education as the History of the Present: Fabrication, Difference and Abjection

10.30am Jean-Michel Chapoulie, University of Paris I

 

A retrospective glance at 50 years of empirical studies in French sociology

11.00am Susan Robertson, University of Bristol

 

The renewal of the sociological framework in a knowledge-based economy

11.30am Discussion

 

Noon Lunch

Afternoon (two sessions in parallel)

Session 1. 2.00pm Governing education after the welfare state President: Philippe Meirieu. Vice-president of the Rhône-Alpes local community in charge of training

Session 2. 2.00pm The sociology of education and new state sciences President : Jean-Claude Zancarini, UMR Triangle (Ecole Normale Supérieure Européenne)

2.15pm Denis Meuret, University of Burgundy, IREDU. IUF   The impact of accountability on education policies in the USA   2.45pm Sally Power, School of Social Sciences, University of Cardiff   Post welfare-state social inclusion: a new model of justice? 3.15pm Helen Gunter, University of Manchester   School leadership: the managerial restructuring of school organisation   3.45pm Dalila Andrade Oliveira, University of Minas Gerais   Educational policies in Brazil and their effects on teacher work 4.15pm Frédéric Pierru, IRISES (institute for research in sociology, economics, and political science), University Paris-Dauphine   The transformations of public health government: towards new solidarity? 4.45 – 5.30pm discussion

2.15pm Antonio Nóvoa, University of Lisbon   Comparatism in education: a sociological approach to types of governance     2.45pm Agnès van Zanten, Observatory of social change   The new management of local education policy by “grandes écoles” 3.15pm Francis Kramarz, Centre for research in economics and statistics , INSEE   Experimentations and quasi-experimentations as government science   3.45pm Martine Mespoulet, University of Nantes   Statistical instrumentation and state initiatives: the Soviet case       4.15 - 5pm discussion

Tuesday 23 November 2010

9.00am Welcoming visitors

9.30am Second session: Education, globalisation and European perspectives

 

9.45am Jenny Ozga, OxfordUniversity

 

Knowledge-based government: the new technologies of production and use of knowledge

10.15am Roger Dale, University of Bristol

 

The sociology of education and the European project of school modernisation

 

10.45am Laurent Thévenot, INSEE (National Institute for statistics and Economic Studies) -EHESS (school for advanced studies in social sciences)

Measurable policies, disputable policies: 50 years of relations between policies, figures, their assessments and scientific theories. (Based on France’s surveys “training and professional qualification”)

 

11.15am Discussion

 

Noon Lunch

 

Afternoon (Two sessions in parallel)

2.00pm Building the European education area President Jean-Richard Cytermann, chief inspector, deputy director at the General Directorate for Research and Innovation (DGRI)

2.00pm Expertise and new forms of knowledge production President Alain Mingat (IREDU, Institute for research in education)

2.15pm Eric Verdier, (LEST, laboratory of the economics and sociology of labour), University of Provence   The new conventions of lifelong learning   2.45pm Gaële Goastellec, University of Lausanne   The measurement of inequalities in education through the perspective of higher education: global challenges, local actors? 3.15pm Sarah Croché, National Fund for Scientific Research (Belgium)   Higher education in Europe and the Bologna process     3.45pm Luis Miguel Carvalho, University of Lisbon   Beyond debates on the interest and limits of international comparison of performance: the fabrication and dissemination of knowledge for policymakers   4.15 – 5.00pm Discussion

2.15pm Cécile Robert, (IEP, Institute of policy studies), University Lyon 2   The place of expertise in the European construction of public policies   2.45pm Jean-Claude Emin, DEP   Reflections on the role of the French department for assessment, forecast, and performance (DEPP)   3.15pm Jean-Emile Charlier, Catholic University of Mons   Determining the quality of higher education     3.45pm Romuald Normand, UMR Éducation & Politiques   Expertise, networks and measurement instruments: the development of a European policy of education 4.15 – 5.00pm Discussion